Arsenal Mustn’t Panic: The Gunners Are Still the Premier League’s Best Team — But Throwing Away the Title Now Could End the Arteta Project

Arsenal don’t lose often. That’s why Saturday’s 2-1 defeat to Aston Villa — only their second league loss of the season — has triggered such loud alarms among fans and critics. Their only other defeat came way back in August against Liverpool, a match that looks far less painful now given how the season has evolved.

Still, there’s a growing sense that this season represents the biggest pressure point of the Mikel Arteta era. Arsenal entered 2025-26 with momentum, elite performances, and a squad finally mature enough to finish what they started. But now the table looks tighter than ever.

The Table Tightens — and So Does the Pressure

Despite being England’s most reliable side for months, Arsenal now sit only two points above Manchester City and three points above Aston Villa. What looked like a one-team march toward the title suddenly has tension again — and the Gunners cannot afford to be pulled back into a dogfight they seemed to have escaped.

A Sudden Dip After a Red-Hot Run

Arsenal’s 4-1 demolition of rivals Tottenham on November 23 felt like a turning point. Eberechi Eze announced himself with a brilliant hat-trick, and a commanding win over Bayern Munich days later placed Arsenal at the top of Europe’s form charts.

But those emotionally and physically draining performances came with a cost.

• Against Chelsea, Arsenal struggled despite playing against 10 men for long periods.

• Brentford made them grind out a difficult 2-0 win.

• Villa delivered the final blow — a 94th-minute winner that ended Arsenal’s 18-game unbeaten run.

It wasn’t just a defeat. It was an emotional punch to the gut.

Carragher’s “Emotional Energy” Warning

Jamie Carragher recently warned that Arsenal’s biggest weakness isn’t tactical — it’s emotional.

He argued that Arsenal often spend too much emotional energy too early in the season, treating every win like a title-clincher and every setback like a disaster.

According to Carragher:

“Players and staff need to remain composed and move on to the next game. This should be their time.”

Arsenal’s reaction to Villa’s late goal — players collapsing in despair, Raya crawling in frustration — only fuels the narrative that the team is emotionally volatile. It may be harmless… or it might become a defining image if the title slips away again.

Injury Problems Return — Again

For the second season in a row, Arsenal are being hammered by injuries. This time, the damage is concentrated in the worst possible place: centre-back.

• Gabriel Magalhães and William Saliba are both out.

• Backup Cristhian Mosquera is sidelined for over a month.

• Arteta was forced to pair full-backs Jurrien Timber and Piero Hincapié in central defence.

Unsurprisingly, the structure wasn’t the same. Arsenal’s elite stability begins with their centre-backs — take them away, and cracks appear.

To their credit, the Gunners have managed to keep winning despite a rotating cast of absentees. But the Villa loss revealed how fragile the balance has become.

The Big Question: Is This Their Moment — Or Their Breaking Point?

Arsenal are still the Premier League’s best team on paper. The structure, the consistency, the numbers — all point to a side finally ready to go all the way.

But here’s the truth:

If Arsenal throw away the title from this position, it will raise serious questions about the entire Arteta project.
This is the strongest squad he has built.
The path is clearer than in previous seasons.
The rivals are wobbling.

Everything is aligned.

And that’s exactly why the pressure is unbearable.

Arsenal shouldn’t panic… not yet.
But they must steady themselves — emotionally, mentally, and defensively — before this wobble becomes something far more catastrophic.