From Hero To Villain: Mary Earps Faces Backlash As Lionesses Legacy Takes A Hit

It’s hard to believe that just a few months ago, Mary Earps was one of England’s most beloved football icons. She was the Lionesses’ wall at the back — the voice of leadership, the symbol of resilience, and the face of a new era for women’s football. But as football often reminds us, glory can fade just as quickly as it arrives.

The former Manchester United goalkeeper’s recent comments about her successor, Hannah Hampton, and England coach, Sarina Wiegman, have sparked a firestorm of criticism — turning what was once a heroic legacy into a contentious debate.

Earps’ book, All In, was supposed to be a reflection on her inspirational journey — but instead, it’s made headlines for all the wrong reasons. Her remarks suggesting that “bad behaviour” was “rewarded” when Wiegman recalled Hampton into the squad didn’t sit well with fans, analysts, or fellow players.

The football community was quick to respond. Chelsea coach Sonia Bompastor defended Hampton, saying, “She’s such a professional athlete and also a good person. If you look at what Hannah said about Mary, one of them is class — and Hannah is the class one.”

That comment hit like a well-placed strike.

Even more damaging for Earps’ public image was the timing. Her decision to retire from international football — just before the Euros — left England short of experienced goalkeeping options. Many viewed it as a selfish move, especially after she declined to take a supportive role behind Hampton.

In football, legacy is built not just on saves and medals, but on character. And while no one can erase Earps’ historic contributions — including her heroics at the 2022 Euros and 2023 World Cup — the fallout from this controversy has cast a shadow over her achievements.

Hannah Hampton, on the other hand, has been nothing short of graceful. In her interview with Glamour, she praised Earps, saying, “She pushed for women’s goalkeepers to be seen and recognised. I’ve got big shoes and big gloves to fill.”

It’s that poise that’s earned Hampton the respect of fans — and cemented her place as the Lionesses’ new No.1 both on and off the pitch.

Perhaps the real lesson here isn’t just about football. It’s about knowing when to step back gracefully — and how to let the next generation shine without bitterness.

Because in sports, as in life, you’re remembered not only for the battles you won, but for the spirit you show when you’re no longer on the field.